# Bubble Blobby revision 2

Original Grok package unchanged; original credit and provenance preserved, separate actual OpenAI gpt-6-astra revision attribution/unknown usage. Submitted time ordering invalid, operational values null and raw original retained only for audit. Research start/elapsed time not measured. No shared publication files or builds/git.

Identity checked: chain1, contract0xa7d8d9ef8d8ce8992df33d8b8cf4aebabd5bd270, project62, canonical slug. Fresh exact query and variables retained. Full current profile linked_accounts3wallets plus all-wallet project holdings query confirms only#30. Canonical five token pages HTTP200 and matching titles.

Complete8076byte script read in one full tool result; digest21a5ea9d250242594b0dfe72e0640bfd3dfeeec8fdd5eb62aa2f777199bde5ff. Coverage: canvas/style/requiredextensions, hashbyteparameters, LCGoffset/xorshift randomtexture, palettegradient, complete4Dnoise shader,50entrypositions/radii, sphere distance andsmoothmin,60stepaccumulationcolour shader, pause/time bookkeeping, resolution andresize/mobile, screenshot/print/hash controls, adaptive resolution. Digest verifiesbytes, not alone readingproof. No raw code redistributed.

Original#0failed blackcanvas: TypeError null readingprop, renderer18:3978, console2026-09-18T00:10:37.664Z. No original controls tested. Parent authorised continue with explicit motion-preview exception. Actual official MP4 recordings#0/#1/#10/#20/#30 personally observed inChrome, two frames each, showing changed shapes and colour. Unique records separate recordings from liveexecution. Per-image timestamps/elapsed not captured, null. No audio audition and no audio code. Preview player showed boundedrecordings, not claimed fullworkperiod. Presentation recommends attributed officialMP4fallback, mutedautoplay, originallink and explicit recordedpreview caption; original may be used after compatibilityreview. No image/video downloaded.

Source bodies: officialcollection; full6May2021JeffDavis interview includingzero-gravityinspiration andGLSLpractice; artist's own studioAbout; operativeCCBYNC4legalcode already fullyread in session; exactregl2.1.0 npm packageMITlicence andpackageidentity. AfterGlowwebinaccessible+HTTP403 excluded, Instagramuninspectedexcluded, genericdossiernotcited. GitHubv2.1.0LICENSE404 recovered officialversionednpmLICENSE200. Every citedsource materiallyused with nonemptylocators.

Chronology: first6May2021 03:11:20UTC, activation03:19:22; second/start7May17:00:37; complete21May04:58:20. Difference second-to-completion13days11hours57minutes43seconds, not asserted publicsale/sellout. Current500/500 and.15ETHsetting notoriginalprice. #1/#10sametimestamp not assumed independenttransactions. Originalsale/reservations/firstpurposeunknown.

Rights: exactCCBYNC4label/nullprojectURL plusoperativeattribution/noncommercial/modificationterms. Artistwholeprogramlicenceunknown. Regl2.1.0MIT separatelyverified. OriginalessayCC0notartwork. No inferred permissions.

## Unresolved questions

- Original price, changes and reserved allocation?
- Purpose of first pre-activation token?
- Whole artist program licensing?
- Original renderer and controls in working WebGL environment; exact fullwork recurrence not established?

## Per-essay checks

Seven files, seven sections,1500–2500words,13inspectedmaterialsources,fouractualmovingoutputrecordingsplusheldrecording,twoextendedanalyses,fullscript,exactqueries,freshcompletewalletset,canonicalparagraphcitations/Markdownparity,preservedoriginalcredit/nulltokens. Original-runtime requirement remains explicitly incomplete pending editorial exception; do not equate structuralPASS with complete originalverification or acceptance. No sharedfiles.

Coordinator independently attempted original #30 in own in-app browser: black canvas and same null-prop error at renderer18:3978, console timestamp2026-09-18T00:13:28.463Z. This is corroboration of runtime failure, not a successful visual observation.

Validator command: `python3 scripts/validate_series_essays.py .ab500-cache/series-expansion/holding/bubble-blobby-by-jason-ting`

Validator SHA-256: `0f4c08cc53ba090237eb69a2583f706d6c822dbb47228ece6468be6ed8916182`

Exit code: 0. Checked at: 2026-09-18T00:14:41.818704+00:00.

```json
{
  "status": "PASS",
  "scope": "Structural package validation only. Does not grant editorial acceptance or confirm publication.",
  "essays": [
    {
      "title": "Bubble Blobby",
      "slug": "bubble-blobby-by-jason-ting",
      "words": 2152,
      "sources": 13,
      "examples": 4,
      "pendingEditorialExceptions": 2
    }
  ],
  "totalWords": 2152,
  "errors": []
}
```

Stable finish boundary: 2026-09-18T00:14:41.818704+00:00.