# Reflection coordinator review

Grok round 004 original preserved. Review triggered by thin construction account, repeated generic methodology, unsupported reserved-mint classification, and an incorrect description of #1's layout. No original token telemetry; preserve Grok self-reported model and Astra revision credit.

## Full code coverage
Read all 5210 UTF-8 bytes; SHA-256 9deb748682c59f9f77fc33a5b1977ce5560b5b6b2367a2afd08a024fac09e8cf matches fresh retrieval and submitted digest. tokenData.hash becomes 32 bytes. setup defines hash-selected rows/columns, frame width, corner curve, four hues/speeds/directions, rotation. draw converts millis to time, applies saturation and relationship branches (all equal, complementary pair, paired independent colours, 45-degree pairs, independent corners), then renders one four-vertex field in WebGL. Black aframe/bframe shapes repeated over grid with 180-degree rotation mask the field. No custom input, audio or resize handler; no noLoop. Window dimensions measured in setup. Runtime p5 1.0.0.

## Primary sources
Official collection page (release 18 Nov 2021, Playground, 100, emotional description and announced 10% Art for Good donation); exact fresh metadata including 1 ETH current setting. Jeff Davis 2021 portfolio: Reflection installation New York, 100 animations, responsive aspect and adaptive resolution; Portal separate. Full Color of Code interview, Alex Estorick, 8 May 2023: retrospective practice context, screen light and bounded editions. CC BY-NC 4 deed; pinned p5 1.0.0 LGPL2.1 text. No launch price or allocation history inferred. Canonical five-token GET outcomes saved separately.

## Original visual inspection
Chrome official generators at 1689 by 852 landscape. Captures made at separate states; intervals not instrumented, so no measured duration or frame-rate claims. No custom control tests or audio audition claimed.
- #0: first inspected in preceding research turn as two side-by-side rounded openings with shared lime-to-muted-to-purple vertical gradient. Two later session captures: purple at top/lime below, then green at top/magenta below.
- #1: four tall columns in one row, slight rounding, substantial black gutters. First blue/cyan with red lower-left; next lime/turquoise upper area and blue/purple below. Corrects Grok two-row description.
- #10: two horizontally long capsules stacked; cyan/pink left-right gradient becomes almost uniform hot pink.
- #20: two rows/two columns, sharp corners, not rounded. Soft violet/pink/cyan changes to warmer upper right and cooler lower right; black cross stable.
- #64: verified AB5D holding, three rows/three columns rounded landscape rectangles. Green and turquoise variation, cooler upper right/lower left, centre/opposite diagonal greener. Second capture visibly more turquoise in those regions; geometry stable.

## Acceptance basis
Five actual original outputs, two sustained readings, eleven materially cited sources. Exact all-linked-wallet owner check; header #64 live. No code redistributed. Historical price, allocations, donation transfer, rights history and pinned-chain comparison are disclosed unknowns, not claims. Corrected source-scope, visual and seed-to-pixel explanations. Original returned sources replaced only where actual useful primary sources were inspected by coordinator.

## Research and acceptance
Full 5210-byte p5 WebGL script inspected; digest verified against retrieval and Grok return. Exact query and variables retained. Token canonical pages GET checked. Five original renderers inspected with changing states. Separate artwork and artist-code rights. Historical payments, allocations, charitable transfer, terms history and pinned-chain comparison unresolved. Per-essay token telemetry unavailable; null metrics. Structural validation alone does not confer editorial acceptance.